More Than Words: Using Strengths-Based Approaches to Build Psychological Safety

Published on 17 November 2026

By Michele Deeks. 

Recent evidence suggests that creating and maintaining workplaces where everyone feels psychologically safe is something we’re making limited progress on. The most recent data from Mental Health First Aid England suggests that only 55% of UK employees feel able to raise mistakes or risks at work. It’s easy to point to changes within the world of work over the last couple of decades that might be contributing to that. And whilst those changes may explain our lack of progress, they also intensify the need for us to do better. 

Defined by Amy Edmondson in the 1990s as ‘a shared belief that the team is safe for interpersonal risk-taking’, psychological safety is a concept that I’ve been talking about and working with organisations on throughout my career.  Sometimes it has been the main reason for a client approaching us, but more often it has been something that has emerged as part of the bigger picture. 

The Challenges of Psychological Safety 

One of the challenges of psychological safety is that it’s much harder to quantify than physical safety. Largely speaking, it’s easy to agree on what makes a workplace physically safe (or not). But I’ve had many a debate with leaders over the kinds of behaviours and management practices that may or may not hinder psychological safety. 

The reality is psychological safety is a very personal experience; it’s about how we feel; it’s a moveable feast, and there is a more tenuous link between risk factor and solution than with physical safety. One day someone may feel psychologically safe; another day they may not. One person may report a high level of psychological safety whilst their teammate – working in the same environment – may not.   

This level of nuance can make it a tricky concept for teams and leaders to gain a shared understanding of. There is certainly no silver bullet, one-stop checklist or perfect training programme that will forever make any team or organisation psychologically safe.   

The Role of Relationships 

Ultimately, psychological safety rests heavily on the quality of relationships within a team. If a staff member feels respected, valued and trusted, and they respect, value and trust their colleagues, they are much more likely to feel confident taking an interpersonal risk. 

Using Strengths-Based Approaches 

A lot of my work centres around embedding strengths-based practices in teams and organisations. We see a clear connection between Ryan and Deci’s Self Determination Theory (SDT) and playing to strengths: When people are playing to their strengths, it increases their sense of competence, autonomy and connectedness, the basic psychological needs identified by SDT. In turn, those needs being met means people are more likely to feel psychologically safe.

A Note of Caution 

It would seem that advising leaders to use strengths-based approaches is a good way to build psychological safety. But it’s not that simple. 

Take the example of a client I worked with recently where the strengths of the senior management team were well understood by the CEO. He did many of the things I would encourage leaders to do – he openly praised people’s strengths, celebrated successes and encouraged people to play to their strengths more of the time. On paper, they looked like a senior management team that should have been thriving with high levels of psychological safety. 

But that wasn’t the case. Although individual performance was generally good (and sometimes exceptional), the team itself was fractured; individual team members were insecure, defensive and reluctant to own mistakes or call out problems. 

What Was Going On? 

Firstly, the organisation was undergoing a lot of change. It was an environment that was always going to be challenging. In addition, the CEO cultivated a competitive culture, frequently comparing and pitting senior team members against each other.   

And that’s where the problems lay. Rather than using personal strengths to pull people together, they were being used in a way that divided the team.    

In my early conversations with the CEO, it was clear that he couldn’t understand what he was doing wrong. He recognised the value of playing to people’s strengths and prided himself on giving positive feedback and showing appreciation. 

Strengths-Based Approaches Need to Be Properly Embedded

But that’s where his use of strengths-based approaches stopped. I would argue that embedding strengths-based approaches is about much more than identifying someone’s strengths and praising them when they use them. To use strengths-based approaches to improve psychological safety, I encourage leaders to focus on three key areas: 

1. Deepening understanding of personal strengths 

It’s essential that individuals properly understand what their strengths are, why they are appreciated and how they add value. It can be daunting (and potentially damaging) to be bestowed with a set of strengths labels that you feel responsible for living up to but that you don’t properly understand.

Our experience is that taking people through a narrative-driven process to identify the strengths they use when they are at their best is a more successful way to help people develop ownership and understanding of their strengths than a questionnaire-based approach. 

2. Exploring and celebrating team strengths 

To properly embed a strengths-based culture, it is important to go beyond ‘me’, to consider the ‘we’ and ‘us’. This means taking time to explore the collective strengths of the team and connecting that to team purpose and personal strengths. In this way, strengths are used to unite rather than to divide, building the relationships that we know are essential for psychological safety. 

3. Managing the context 

We need to be mindful of the broader context and of making sure people feel supported within it. In the client example I’ve shared, one of the ongoing challenges was people feeling vulnerable because the expectation was that they would play to their strengths all of the time, except that high work demands made that difficult.

Leaders play a key role here, helping to manage the context where they can and making expectations clear through their own actions and communications: whilst we should strive to apply our strengths optimally, it’s not always possible; we don’t always get it right, and that’s OK. 

Conclusion 

A more comprehensive implementation of a strengths-based approach, as discussed, can help people feel valued rather than vulnerable. Focusing on the ‘we’ and ‘us’ can help people to understand how they and everyone else contribute and why they matter. Celebrating everyone’s strengths and the positive impact they have helps make it clear that all strengths are equally valued.

Ultimately, the aim is to shift the patterns of interaction, to shine a spotlight more frequently on what is working, which in turn gives people that sense of competence, autonomy and connectedness that can build psychological safety. 

 

For ABP Members:

Not yet a member? We invite you to join us at The Association for Business Psychology!

 

About the Author

A Chartered Psychologist with over 25 years of experience, Michele Deeks, CPsychol, AFBPsS, HCPC reg combines her expertise as an occupational psychologist and her passion for positive psychology to focus on developing simple, practical solutions to help leaders, managers and staff to flourish. As a director of Work Positive and a co-creator of the At My Best range of products, Michele uses strengths-based and appreciative approaches to work with organisations who are looking to empower their leaders and maximise the wellbeing of their people. Her favourite thing about her work? Seeing the big differences small changes can make (and what happens when people realise that!) Contact: [email protected] 

References  

Edmondson, A (1999) Psychological Safety and Learning Behavior in Work Teams, Administrative Science Quarterly, Vol. 44, No. 2, pp. 350-383. Available at: https://www.jstor.org/stable/2666999?origin=JSTOR-pdf 

Mental Health First Aid (2026) The cost of workplace silence: Nearly half of employees feel unsafe speaking up at work, new research reveals. Available at: https://mhfaengland.org/news-and-blogs/the-cost-of-workplace-silence-nearly-half-of-employees-feel-unsafe-speaking-up-at-work-new-research-reveals/ (Accessed 30th October 2026) 

Ryan, R.M, Deci, E.L (2000) Self-Determination Theory and the Facilitation of Intrinsic Motivation, Social Development, and Well-Being, American Psychologist, Vol 55. No. 1 p68-78. Available at: https://selfdeterminationtheory.org/SDT/documents/2000_RyanDeci_SDT.pdf